Gwynne Dyer: Egypt massacres of anti-coup protesters are worse than a crime | Georgia Straight

Gwynne Dyer: Egypt massacres of anti-coup protesters are worse than a crime | Georgia Straight... 30/07/2013 News

Keywords:#Cairo, #Egypt, #Egyptian, #French, #Georgia, #Islamic, #Morsi, #Muslim, #Muslim_Brotherhood, #Napoleon,, #Tahrir_Square

Two massacres committed by the Egyptian army in one week. At least 130 people killed in the streets of Cairo for protesting against the military coup.

It is worse than a crime (as the French diplomat Talleyrand remarked when Napoleon ordered a particularly counter-productive execution). It is a mistake.

It is also a crime, of course. The killing has been deliberate and precise: only trained snipers could produce so many victims who have been shot in the head or the heart. General Abdel Fattah al-Sisi and Adly Mansour, the tame president he has installed, tell the kind of lies that generals and politicians always tell when this sort of thing is going on, but the reports of the journalists on the scene leave no room for doubt: this is murder.

But it is, above all, a mistake. When the army fulfilled the demands of the anti-government demonstrators in Tahrir Square on July 3 by overthrowing the elected president, Mohammed Morsi, after only a year in office, it must have known that his supporters in the Muslim Brotherhood would protest in the streets. And it must have had a plan for dealing with those protests. Soldiers always have plans.

The simplest plan would be just to wait the protesters out. The Muslim Brotherhood could put large numbers of people on the streets, but at least in Cairo even larger number of people would go to Tahrir Square and support the coup. Use minimum force, contain the demonstrations by both sides, and wait for people to get bored and go home.

In the meanwhile, push on with the process of rewriting the constitution to remove the Islamic bits inserted last year by Morsi’s party and hold a new referendum to ratify it. By the time fresh presidential and parliamentary elections are held early next year, the Muslim Brotherhood will presumably have found more modern and moderate leaders to replace Morsi—and, in any case, the secular parties will win the election. This is murder. But it is, above all, a mistake....

Read more from Source »

Related articles based on keyword density
Alray - Israel behind Morsi's ouster, Erdogan says - Media Agency... 27/08/2013 News
Gaza, Alray - Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan says Israel is behind the overthrow of Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi, whose administratio...View Details»

Iran condemns use of force in Egypt... 17/08/2013 News
The Iranian Foreign Ministry in a statement on Wednesday condemned the use of force and massacre of people in Egypt, and called on all involved parti...View Details»

Egypt’s Morsi Trial Quickly Adjourns After He and Defendants Chant Def... 04/11/2013 News
Nov. 4, 2013 7:50am Sharona Schwartz The judge presiding over the trial of former Egyptian President Mohammed Morsi adjourned the proceedings on Monda...View Details»

Time to cut military aid to Egypt - Eugene Robinson... 18/08/2013 News
There may be little the United States can do to end the savage bloodletting in Egypt, but at least our nation can be loyal to its ideals by bearing wi...View Details»

Saudi demands Qatar 'shut down Al-Jazeera' ... 16/03/2014 News
Dubai (AFP) - Saudi Arabia demanded that Qatar shut down Al-Jazeera and two think tanks during a recent meeting of the Gulf Cooperation Council, a sou...View Details»