EU Loses Two New Iran, Syria Sanctions Legal Cases - WSJ

EU Loses Two New Iran, Syria Sanctions Legal Cases - WSJ... 04/07/2014 News

Keywords:#Baath, #EU, #European_Union, #Iran, #Iranian, #Laurence_Norman, #Legal, #Nations,, #Russia, #Sanctions, #Sharif_University, #Sharif_University_of_Technology, #Syria, #Syrian, #Ukraine, #United_Nations

By Laurence Norman July 3, 2014 6:00 a.m. ET

The European Union lost two new sanctions cases Thursday, with the bloc's second highest court overturning the EU's decisions to blacklist Iran's Sharif University of Technology and former Syrian Economy and Trade Minister Mohamad Nedal Alchaar.

The decisions by the EU General Court are the latest defeats the bloc has suffered as it seeks to uphold dozens of decisions in recent years to impose asset freezes and travel bans on hundreds of individuals and companies in Iran and Syria.

Those defeats, caused in part by repeated demands by the court for more detailed evidence, have weighed on the bloc as it mulls how far to push sanctions now on Russia over Ukraine case, diplomats have said.

In many cases, member states have refused to provide confidential evidence to the judges because the court's rules mean some of that information has to be made available to lawyers for those appealing the sanctions.

In the case of Sharif University, the EU had imposed an asset freeze for "providing support to Iran's proliferation of sensitive nuclear activities." The EU said the university provided laboratories for use by two firms sanctioned by the United Nations and the EU, respectively.

"The General Court considers that the council committed a manifest error of assessment and failed to discharge the burden of proof which rests on it," the court said in a news release.

The court said the bloc sent documents justifying the university's listing after the permitted date and that the documents "contain no information or material which adds anything to" the case against the university. The court said the EU member state which proposed listing the university opposed sharing a confidential document to back up the claim.

"There is nothing to support the claims that SUT assisted the entities…to violate the restrictive measures adopted against Iran, or provided direct support to Iranian nuclear activities," the court said.

The court said it would give the European Council two months before lifting the asset freeze. That could allow the EU to sanction the university on different grounds.

In the case of Mr. Alchaar, the court said the EU was within its rights to sanction him while he was a government minister without providing additional evidence. But, the court said, after Mr. Alchaar, a leading economist, left office in May 2012 the EU had to be able to provide evidence of his continued links to the Assad regime and his joint responsibility for government actions.

"The General Court states however that the council did not provide such evidence," the court said in a news release.

It said the EU "improperly" decided that the burden of proof was on Mr. Alchaar to establish he is no longer tied to the Assad regime.

The court also accused the EU of failing "to examine carefully and impartially" evidence provided by the former minister that he wasn't a member of Mr. Assad's Baath Party, didn't exercise political responsibilities and opposed the use of violence to solve the Syrian crisis.

With the EU continuing to lose cases, member states have been seeking ways to legally ring-fence their sanctions regime for months now. In the spring, the General Court submitted proposals which would make it easier for member states to provide confidential evidence to the court without that information being fully shared.

Those proposals are currently under discussion with member states due to meet again to discuss the ideas later in July. However, people involved in the talks say it will still be months before any decision is made.

Write to Laurence Norman at Laurence.Norman@wsj, com
---The EU has lost two new sanctions cases, with the bloc's second highest court overturning the EU's decisions to blacklist Iran's Sharif University of Technology and former Syrian minister Mohamad Nedal Alchaar.---

Read more from Source »

Related articles based on keyword density
Global “Elders” urge Iran to build on nuclear deal - The Washington Po... 28/01/2014 Politics
TEHRAN, Iran — The former head of the United Nations urged Iran Monday to build on a historic deal reached with world powers in November and work towa...View Details»

Middle East - Security Council debates ending UN sanctions on Iran ... 13/03/2015 News
Major world powers have begun talks about a UN Security Council resolution to lift UN sanctions on Iran if a nuclear agreement is struck with Tehran, ...View Details»

Iran and 6 Powers Agree on Terms for Nuclear Talks... 21/02/2014 Politics
By STEVEN ERLANGERFEB. 20, 2014 VIENNA — In what officials described as a serious, workmanlike and conversational atmosphere, Iran and six world pow...View Details»

ISIS: The Spoils of the "Great Loot" in the Middle East - FPIF... 02/07/2014 Politics
Adding yet more warfare to the current crisis in the Middle East will perpetuate exactly what the imperial powers set out to do: tear an entire region...View Details»

Since it Failed in Syria, America Now Targets Hezbollah | Global Res... 07/08/2013 News
By Mahdi Darius Nazemroaya After Hezbollah intervened in Syria, cursory analysis began circulating that the Iranians had ordered their Lebanese partne...View Details»